Donna Troy's death - possibly lamer than Hawkeye's

[allanpat]

His Red hood storyline was a very good Batman story and I liked his Outsiders also.

yeah, i heard the red hood was okay until the annual came out...
judging from responses on this board Graduation Day is the most detested of his work so far....

If i were to give Winick a second shot, what book?
Green Arrow
Batman: Red Hood
Outsiders
Exiles

[ds9]

yeah, i heard the red hood was okay until the annual came out...
judging from responses on this board Graduation Day is the most detested of his work so far....

If i were to give Winick a second shot, what book?
Green Arrow
Batman: Red Hood
Outsiders
Exiles

I say buy the 2 Batman trades because they are nice and cheap 9 a piece. Im going to buy Outsiders and Green Arrow.

[Blandy vs Terrorism]

yeah, i heard the red hood was okay until the annual came out...
judging from responses on this board Graduation Day is the most detested of his work so far....

If i were to give Winick a second shot, what book?
Green Arrow
Batman: Red Hood
Outsiders
Exiles

I thought his Exiles run was really good, and heard similar opinions from others.

[Ray G.]

Horrible story. Winick is very hit and miss. I liked his Batman(until the last issue), and he's had some pretty good stories in Outsiders. Both his run on GA and GL had some highs and lows. The Ion storyarc is probably my favorite thing he's ever written.

But this was just laaaaaaaaaame. And we now know that the whole thing was just a weak set-up for a storyline two years in the future. Young Justice deserved better than this.

[ds9]

Horrible story. Winick is very hit and miss. I liked his Batman(until the last issue), and he's had some pretty good stories in Outsiders. Both his run on GA and GL had some highs and lows. The Ion storyarc is probably my favorite thing he's ever written.

But this was just laaaaaaaaaame. And we now know that the whole thing was just a weak set-up for a storyline two years in the future. Young Justice deserved better than this.

Why noone bought it?

[Dreg]

Young Justice deserved better than this.

With the exception of Slobo, most were more entertaining than the grabbag of gimmicks that was Donna Troy.

[Ray G.]

Why noone bought it?

It was a fun book with a mid-level audience. DC wanted to punch it up, and bring the Titans name back to its roots. Not a bad idea. But the title deserved better than to end with such a whimper in this mini. There were so many great characters who were just abandoned. Same with the PAD Supergirl. I don't blame DC for canceling them, but the legacy shouldn't be ignored.

[WinstonWolf]

Wait a tic. There actually WAS a death that was lamer than Hawkeyes? Man. I might have to check this one out just for that.

[TheTravis!]

yeah, i heard the red hood was okay until the annual came out...
judging from responses on this board Graduation Day is the most detested of his work so far....

If i were to give Winick a second shot, what book?
Green Arrow
Batman: Red Hood
Outsiders
Exiles

Winnick's Exiles is fucking amazing.
His Green Arrow is pretty fun.
His Green Lantern was kind of awful.
His Outsiders looked pretty but had horrible mischaracterizations of almost every character.
I only read part of his Batman run, but I dug it.

[ds9]

Winnick's Exiles is fucking amazing.
His Green Arrow is pretty fun.
His Green Lantern was kind of awful.
His Outsiders looked pretty but had horrible mischaracterizations of almost every character.
I only read part of his Batman run, but I dug it.

The Outsiders was full of new characters for the most part.