Bsg...

[BronxRonin]

My favorite show on television.
outta

[Sy-Klone]

Pretty good episode!

A few comments, hidden for spoilers:

Spoiler:

That first scene with Helo and Athena made me physically wince in agony. Gut-wrenching but powerful.

Loved the shuffling of the chess pieces that happened in this episode: Baltar back on Galactica; Six is a prisoner, too; D'Anna's model is boxed for the foreseeable future.

Loved D'Anna's viewing of the Final Five. In particular, that last one she saw: "You? I'm so sorry. I had no idea." That is such a tease, and suggests two options: 1.) that Cylon is a very prominent member of the cast OR 2.) that Cylon is a human that was treated badly by D'Anna at some point.

The reveal about Starbuck was extremely well done.

That said, the stuff with Starbuck and Apollo making goo goo eyes at each other is getting a little tiresome.

Can't wait to see where this goes next.

[Mr. E!]

Pretty good episode!

A few comments, hidden for spoilers:

Spoiler:

That first scene with Helo and Athena made me physically wince in agony. Gut-wrenching but powerful.

Loved the shuffling of the chess pieces that happened in this episode: Baltar back on Galactica; Six is a prisoner, too; D'Anna's model is boxed for the foreseeable future.

Loved D'Anna's viewing of the Final Five. In particular, that last one she saw: "You? I'm so sorry. I had no idea." That is such a tease, and suggests two options: 1.) that Cylon is a very prominent member of the cast OR 2.) that Cylon is a human that was treated badly by D'Anna at some point.

The reveal about Starbuck was extremely well done.

That said, the stuff with Starbuck and Apollo making goo goo eyes at each other is getting a little tiresome.

Can't wait to see where this goes next.

I would have liked to have seen that, but the broadcast flzzed out twice...I'm recording the midnight showing. Bastardry.

[Sy-Klone]

I would have liked to have seen that, but the broadcast flzzed out twice...I'm recording the midnight showing. Bastardry.

That's not good.

Well, at least they're airing it again in an hour, so maybe it'll have straightened itself out by then.

Also, I have to confess: As nerdy as it makes me sound, I prefer the show on Fridays. It gives me something to look forward to all week, and after a draining work week, it'd be great to sit down and geek out on Friday nights. Sunday nights I'm bracing myself for a new work week, and it's just not as fun.

[Jonny Z]

Pretty good episode!

A few comments, hidden for spoilers:

[HIDE]
Loved D'Anna's viewing of the Final Five. In particular, that last one she saw: "You? I'm so sorry. I had no idea." That is such a tease, and suggests two options: 1.) that Cylon is a very prominent member of the cast OR 2.) that Cylon is a human that was treated badly by D'Anna at some point.

Spoiler:

it pretty much has to be a cast member that we all know... i don't think the producers would be jerky enough to fake us out like that. pretty much can't be helo or lee or starbuck, i'm thinking it's tigh. maybe she was apologizing for all the torture they put him through. i'd be pretty bummed out if it was admiral adama

[The Roman Candle]

Spoiler:

it pretty much has to be a cast member that we all know... i don't think the producers would be jerky enough to fake us out like that. pretty much can't be helo or lee or starbuck, i'm thinking it's tigh. maybe she was apologizing for all the torture they put him through. i'd be pretty bummed out if it was admiral adama

Spoiler:

It couldn't be Adama. He has kids, and Hera is supposedly the first child of Cylons.

It would be pretty boss if it was Tigh, though. I hate that guy.

[Jonny Z]

Spoiler:

It couldn't be Adama. He has kids, and Hera is supposedly the first child of Cylons.

It would be pretty boss if it was Tigh, though. I hate that guy.

Spoiler:

yeah, that's partially my point as to why i'd hate it if they made admiral adama a cylon. they'd have to say that his kids were as a result of either them being the first hybrids, or him using a turkey baster on his wife every time they conceived. also, i find it to be unecessary in regards to the overall plot of the series. why make the most important character, the leader, an enemy?

[The Roman Candle]

Spoiler:

yeah, that's partially my point as to why i'd hate it if they made admiral adama a cylon. they'd have to say that his kids were as a result of either them being the first hybrids, or him using a turkey baster on his wife every time they conceived. also, i find it to be unecessary in regards to the overall plot of the series. why make the most important character, the leader, an enemy?

Yeah, I doubt that very much, as well. Such a result would recall the Nina debacle on the first season of 24. It just wouldn't make sense.

[Mr. E!]

Spoiler:

it pretty much has to be a cast member that we all know... i don't think the producers would be jerky enough to fake us out like that. pretty much can't be helo or lee or starbuck, i'm thinking it's tigh. maybe she was apologizing for all the torture they put him through. i'd be pretty bummed out if it was admiral adama

I don't think it could be

Spoilers:

one of the older cast members. The human Cylon models are relatively new (even though some of them are aged, like the Dean Stockwell model), being developed within the last 40 years or so after the First Cylon War. Adama and Tigh are out. They have known each other at least that long, and both served in the first war. Adama has kids, so that bumps him out of the running. Rosslyn is too old as well. Helo knocked up Athena, so we know it can't be him. Can't be Apollo, he's Adama's son. Cally and the Chief are out as well, as they were able to reproduce. Leaving the background pilots and occasional characters out of it, (Kat, Hot Dog, RaceTrack, etc...) out of it, that leaves us with:

That leaves

Spoilers:

Starbuck, Sam, Gaeta, Dee, Dr. Cottle, Tom Zerek (could be an aged model, but their age probably excludes them), Ellen, Billy (No one said they had to be currently alive on Galactica) and Baltar, (But I think that's been well quashed in the show.

Out of those,

Spoilers:

I think Gaeta makes the most sense. He's been involved in pivotal moments of the series (the computer virus infection he "stopped", the fixed election he exposed, his work with Baltar) I don't think he knows it himself, but he makes as much sense as anyone.

[Jonny Z]

Out of those,

Spoilers:

I think Gaeta makes the most sense. He's been involved in pivotal moments of the series (the computer virus infection he "stopped", the fixed election he exposed, his work with Baltar) I don't think he knows it himself, but he makes as much sense as anyone.

Spoiler:

i think either in the mini series or in the first couple of episodes, gaeta has a moment where i said "HE'S A CYLON!" i can't remember the moment now, but ill go back and take a look. he did something while on the bridge that made me jump out of my seat though and call him out as a cylon. since then though, he's become so cool that i'd be sad if he were a cylon.